What if there is more beyond traditional church and talk therapy models? How do we use the transformative tools of psychology and theology, but also not get stuck in models that lack responsiveness to these times? Theologians, Dwight Friesen and Joel Kiekintveld, join in conversation with psychologist, Paul Hoard, as they explore the question of therapeutic models beyond church pews and the therapy couch. Drawing on insights from psychoanalyst, Jacques Lacan, and sociologist, Philip Rieff, they explore alternative pathways to discourse that critique the assumption that knowledge is held through mastery, control, and order.
Transcript
Lauren Peiser: Welcome. Great to see you all. We’ll start in just a moment. As people are logging on, we’ll give people a moment to log on, but welcome. It’s good to see you all.
Okay, looks like we have a good amount of people here. So we’re going to go ahead and get started.
Hi. I’m Lauren Peiser, director of partnerships at The Seattle School, and you are joining our second webinar in our faculty webinar series. And this is a chance for you to get to hear from our faculty and friends at The Seattle School. This is their second in a series of five. Last month we had Dr. Monique Gadson with us. She’s a psychology professor at The Seattle School, and she talked about listening to these times. So if you haven’t checked that out yet, you can find that on our YouTube page.
But today we have three professors here, Dr. Dwight Friesen, Dr. Paul Hoard, and Dr. Joel Kiekintveld. And I’ve asked them to lead a conversation for us today on the interplay with pastors and therapists and what we can imagine beyond traditional church and talk therapy. And they’ve done this at a few conferences before, and it’s gone really well, and so I asked them to do a webinar for us today on it. I’ll let them introduce themselves in a moment, and we’ll give them a chance to share more about the content.
But before we get started, I want to share just a little bit more about why we are doing this webinar series with faculty at The Seattle School. So as I said, my name is Lauren Peiser, the director of partnerships. And a lot of my role is speaking with people outside of our walls. And that includes future counselors and ministers, but it also includes nonprofit workers, city planners, coaches, spiritual directors, and many others who are talking about tending to our world with attention and care. And so many things that I hear faculty talk about in the classroom feel relevant beyond just the vocation of minister and counselor. The integration of theology and psychology is so relevant to where we’re at now. And the ability to listen and respond attentively to what we’re facing in our accelerated modern world is so important.
I’m not personally a therapist or a minister, but I come alive when I get to hear these thoughts and ideas. And I wanted a way for more people to be able to hear this. And so these conversations are to attend to the world that feels fragmented. The times ahead are uncertain, and it’s hard not to move towards despair. And instead of slowing down and listening to ourselves and our neighbors, we often look for quick fixes and disembodied solutions. And so that’s what this conversation series is about. It’s an educational space that honors formation without fixing, curiosity over control, and being with rather than solving uncertainty.
So, what you can expect from these conversations is just a short conversation to be able to slow down and listen and ask questions about why we’re here now, and not just offer a solution to the problem, but go a little bit deeper into what God is saying and what our bodies are saying. And this is scholarship across all disciplines. So, at The Seattle School, our learning values are to help people become embodied listeners, meaning makers, and community healers. And we believe that we need embodied listeners, meaning makers, and community healers across disciplines, vocations, and perspectives. And that is why we are glad that you’re here today listening with us.
So, before I hand it over to Dwight, just Zoom etiquette here. You can use the chat. Please do not add any links in the chat. We’ll delete those if they’re added in the chat. But you can respond to prompts from faculty in the chat directly. And you can use the chat at any point. If something’s coming up for you, if you have a comment, something that you’re thinking about, please feel free to use the chat to respond to faculty. And then use the Q&A feature to ask questions that you want to have answered at the end. And you can use this at any time during the call. So if something comes up for you as one of the faculty are talking, feel free to use the Q&A feature and we will answer those questions at the end. And I know for some people the chat can be overwhelming because there’s noise in there. So if you don’t like looking at it, you can close it at any point. You’re welcome to use it or not use it however you would like. So with that I am going to pass it over to Dwight.
Dwight Friesen: Oh, well hey, thanks everybody for joining us today, and thank you Lauren for that introduction. Actually, that was so fun to hear you describe our school, and it’s like, I want to be at a place like that. And so thank you for the introduction.
So just before opening up and actually leaning into our conversation, Beyond Pews and Couches: Exploring Collective Care Outside the Church and Talk Therapy, I thought we would take a few moments to actually introduce you to some of The Seattle School faculty who will be facilitating our conversation and our learning today. So I’m going to start with Dr. Joel Kiekintveld. And Joel is the author of a new book, or co-editor of a new book called Urban Gems. Joel, introduce us to yourself. Tell us a little bit about who you are, what you care about, where you are, that kind of a thing.
Joel Kiekintveld: Sure. Where I am is always a little bit of a trick, because my wife and I live in our van. So that’s usually the first question when I get on any call, is where are you? But I’m a practical theologian who’s based in Anchorage, Alaska. I have been in ministry for the last, well, over 30 years now. So I’m starting to sound like that old guy who says things like “back when I started.” But over that time I have been a youth pastor, a pastor, a nonprofit executive director, have worked inside of faith-based nonprofits and inside of a state organization working with youth as well. So it really came to the work that I’m doing now with Seattle School and with authoring and some other things as a practitioner. So I’ve always been sort of a ministry practitioner that has then kept asking questions that have led me back to school and back into different things, and the questions have changed. So, but I still currently live in Anchorage. That’s changing at the end of the summer, when my wife and I are going to spend some time in the lower 48 for a year. But two of my daughters and their spouses live here. I have a daughter and her family that live in Wenatchee, Washington with our two grandkids, and they keep me grounded in their places as well. But that’s a little bit about who I am. So, thanks Dwight.
Dwight Friesen: You bet. Thank you, Joel. Dr. Paul Hoard, give us a sense of who you are. By the way, Dr. Paul Hoard and his sister Billie co-authored a book called Eucontamination. Both of these books, by the way, came out this past year. So, a little plug: early Christmas gifts for y’all. Paul, tell us a little bit about who you are, what you care about.
Paul Hoard: Thanks for that, Dwight. Yeah, so my name is Paul Hoard. I’ve been at The Seattle School since the fall of 2021. I came here from Kansas, and before that I was living in Türkiye. Before that, Indiana. So, I’ve sort of been all over. I am a mental health counselor and a psychoanalytic psychotherapist. So, I teach on the counseling psychology side. I’ve been doing mental health and counseling and supervising and teaching in that since I got my masters back in 2010. So, that’s a lot. The role of therapy, the way it’s been playing out in society, and what it means for us is a whole lot of what I’ve been thinking about. I’m pretty excited to continue this conversation with Joel and Dwight. But I live on the Kitsap Peninsula, so across the water from Seattle. I get the pleasure of commuting in by ferry when I go into the school, which is a lot of fun. Not many places you can be late to work because of orcas. So, shout out to the Puget Sound for that. I do enjoy that. I’m also a huge board game nerd, and I love to talk about the significance and importance of play. And so that’s a thread that’ll probably make its way in here today, but the way that play interacts with what we’re doing and how we can learn to play better with each other. I’m glad to be here.
Dwight Friesen: Awesome. Thank you, Paul. And again, I’m Dr. Dwight Friesen, professor of practical theology. I’ve been here and part of the Seattle School of Theology and Psychology since 2004. And I guess I would describe my work as sort of being located at the intersection of local communities of Christ followers, aka the church, and human and planetary flourishing. Basically, trying to learn how to love God by loving our neighbor and our neighborhoods is kind of what I’m about. I live over on the east side in the Lake Hills neighborhood and trying to figure out what it is to be a good neighbor. And today for our conversation, I get to serve as our moderator. That’s kind of my role.
But as we begin in our conversation today, I actually don’t want to jump into theory just yet, or into the big ideas. I actually want us to locate ourselves in our own bodies and in our own experience. And so in order to do that, let me just share my screen here.
Here’s the thing I’d like to invite you to do for just a moment. Take a second and just pause briefly and see if you can identify a moment in your own life where you felt the desire for care. Something was going on in your life and you felt the need to have someone who could see you, join you, care for you, so that you knew deep in your being that you were not alone, or at least not as alone as you fear you might have been. Just pause and see if you can identify a moment when you felt the desire for care.
Okay, you got one. Now, here’s the question. Where did you turn? Where did you turn to find that care?
You don’t have to respond. Hold that question in your thoughts, minds, and bodies, and then as we kind of move on. But that’s our big question for today, as we’re exploring the question of what is it to live beyond pews and couches, and as we’re exploring our collective care outside the church and talk therapy. Our big question is this. Now, this is us sounding as an academic institution. How might Lacan and Rieff help us imagine collective care outside the church and talk therapy? I love this question. How might Lacan and Rieff help us imagine collective care outside the church and talk therapy? And why does this question matter? This is what we’re going to lean into. We’re going to begin by having Dr. Joel Kiekintveld bring Rieff into our conversation. Then I’m going to invite Dr. Paul Hoard to bring Jacques Lacan into our conversation. And then we’re going to invite the two of them to have Rieff and Lacan dance together and see how can these two help us expand our imaginations for what this might look like to find collective care. So that’s kind of the big idea. And again, as Lauren had mentioned earlier on, at any point as you are engaging or listening, you are able to enter your questions into the question area and we will address those at the end of our time. So Joel, why don’t you start us off? How might Rieff help us imagine collective care outside of the church and talk therapy, or wherever you want to take us? Bring Rieff into the room for us.
Joel Kiekintveld: Sure. I’ll back up just a slight bit before we get to Philip Rieff, but I think for me as a practical theologian, as a practitioner, and just I think as just a human, over the last number of years, probably 20, 25 years, I keep looking for ways to sort of understand what’s going on in the world around us. So the way I was trained to do ministry in the mid ’90s, and the early work that I did, at some point it felt like something’s changing, but I don’t know quite how to grab on to that or understand that, or things felt different. So I’m always looking, and that’s where this comes from for me, why I’m bringing Rieff into the room. I also feel it’s a little bit like anytime my wife plans a party, it starts out as “we’re going to have the kids over,” and then she invites five more people that’ll join us, and then our Thanksgiving always has like three extra random people that aren’t normally part of our thing. So, I’m sure I’m going to invite all my other buddies in the room, like Charles Taylor and Hartmut Rosa too, but those are all lenses that have sort of brought me into how do I understand what’s going on around me.
And that has brought me largely, helpfully, to the practical theologian Andrew Root, who I’ve begun listening to a lot. And it was his podcast last year. I was listening to it at the gym like I normally do. He started talking about Philip Rieff. And Lauren’s going to put the link. I know we said no links, and right away I’m breaking the rules, but Lauren’s going to put a link in the chat box to that particular podcast if you’re interested in hearing Root explain Rieff. But he started explaining Philip Rieff a little bit, and the light bulb went off for me. I’m like, “Oh, this is another helpful way to sort of think about what is going on kind of in the world at the moment.” And I, very non-academically, sent that to Paul and Dwight and said, “Hey, this might be something we could discuss at a conference that we were headed to.” This is a jumping off point for where we might go.
So, I’m not an expert on Rieff. I will say what I know about him today. I find this framework that I’m going to explain in just a moment, of the idea of the four worlds, to be really helpful and really generative, in particular when we get to the fourth world. And I’ll explain why when we get there.
A couple of things about Rieff before we get going with him. He’s an American sociologist that was born in the ’20s. He’s known for kind of his cultural criticism. I will say right off the bat, conservatives in particular, very hard-right folks, love Philip Rieff. It’ll probably become clear in a moment why that is. But he’s very concerned with sort of the world and how we think about the world and how we in some ways navigate or understand or control the world. Conservatives tend to latch on to him because he’s very concerned about the morality of things, and he also has this idea of sort of the elites, whoever that is, of the world are the ones who should be setting what the moral code is for any particular time and place.
He’s known for two books early in his career. One was Freud: The Mind of the Moralist that came out in 1959, and then The Triumph of the Therapeutic that came out in 1966. And then interestingly, he doesn’t write a lot for the next 30 years while he teaches at the University of Pennsylvania. He sort of makes this big splash in the late ’50s, early ’60s, and then sort of fades away until right towards the end of his life, and then there’s a kind of a wave of thinking and writing that comes out from him.
He has this idea that he begins to paint in that late ’60s period, of the idea of four worlds. And he talks about that the first world is this world that is what he would call the mythic or fate-driven world. You could think of it as maybe the ancient world. In that world, order is controlled or justified by the myth or the cosmic narrative. So you can think about stories of Greek heroes or Roman gods, those type of things. And that is sort of the controlling dynamic. That’s how people understand the world, that it’s something like, you don’t want to make the gods angry. The gods are in control of things and they’re navigating things. So things sort of happen on their own from this social order that’s out there somewhere, controlled. And the most important person in that world, the elite that Rieff is interested in in that world, he would say is the seer or the mystic. The person that knows what the story is, what the gods are about, what their powers are, what they might be up to. But it’s sort of this mythic or fate-driven world. And that’s maybe a world we don’t connect so much to anymore.
The second world might sound a little more familiar. He says then we move to this second world that is driven by faith or divine authority, and it’s rooted in revelation or transcendent law. You can think of it as scripture and dogma. This is the era of Christianity, of Islam. And in this era, the moral justification for what’s going on is the church or the belief system. And in that sense, the most important person is the priest or the pastor or the imam, whoever the spiritual person is that is telling the story, that is interpreting the text, that is the holder of the dogma or the theology. That’s the person there. And the divine authority sort of sets the social order, like what’s right and wrong, how things should be run. And for many of us on this call, I think this sounds familiar. We grew up in environments that are similar to this. Even if the entire culture wasn’t operating this way, this might sound familiar.
He begins after that to say that a shift happened in the 20th century, towards the end of the 20th century, moving away from that transcendent, sort of religion-based understanding of the world to what he would call an anti-culture, or a culture that denies transcendent grounding. Here he starts to sound a little bit like Charles Taylor, where Taylor’s big question in his book A Secular Age is why 500 years ago it was impossible to not believe in Christianity in the western world, and why now it’s almost impossible to believe.
And that marks this shift from the second world to the third world. And in the third world, what becomes important is not the outside transcendent law or religious order. It is more what is good for me. What is the thing that makes me feel good? How do I flourish? Dwight and I were having a conversation about flourishing before we started up this conversation. It becomes that sort of therapeutic world. And in that world, the therapist becomes the most important person, because that’s the person that’s helping you get to this world where your needs are being met, you feel like life is going as it should, that your kind of goals are happening.
Rieff interestingly sees that as sort of an anti-culture. He doesn’t think it’s culture, because it’s lost some sense of overall narrative. And he begins to talk about some of this therapeutic culture as “death works.” He’s in alignment there with what Taylor is saying about this move away from the transcendent as well. Charles Taylor uses this word of, we used to be in a buffered world, where the spiritual world was very close. There was an angel or a demon underneath every rock and around every corner. Now we don’t think that way. That’s not the first place our brains go. We are sort of in some ways removed from that. So in that sense Taylor, who’s coming at it from a philosophical lens, and Rieff, who’s coming at it from a sociological lens, are kind of on the same page.
Interestingly, and this is where I really found myself, those moves from the second to the third made a lot of sense to me in observing where we’ve been over the last 50, 75 years as a culture. But interestingly, Rieff, towards the end of his life, begins to speculate about, are we moving into a fourth world? And that’s really at the core of what we’re, I think, trying to get at today, is how do we imagine where we’re at at the moment?
In the third world, Rieff really says it can’t be sustained, because there’s no moral code other than what’s true for me, what’s kind of my own understanding of what’s true, which Taylor calls the age of authenticity. We don’t have time to dive all the way into that, but they’re very similar, of this idea of what’s true for me is what is truth. We even say things like that, right? My truth. Tell my truth. Rieff is skeptical of that. He doesn’t feel like that has enough support for the culture. So, he believes that we’re going to move into some kind of fourth world. And he begins to speculate a little bit about this. He doesn’t give a real clear idea, but he hints that maybe it’s a monastic world, where people move back into very strong, and not that I think monasteries are this way, but more of a theological control, a religious control, where you’re living a world that’s ordered by, if you’ve ever been to a monastery, the bells ring for all the different prayers. You have kind of a structure that guides you. He says, or we’ll move towards authoritarianism, because there isn’t a controlling dynamic, we will look for someone or a movement to create that for us.
And this is where another sociologist, Hartmut Rosa, would say the world’s ultimately uncontrollable, but we find ways to control it, and we try to make an uncertain world certain. And I think that’s a little bit of what Rieff is bumping up against, is this idea that in the fourth world, we will move back to some kind of managing principle. And for him, it’s morality. What will be the morality of that? What I find interesting with Rieff, and why the light bulb was going off for me while I was on the treadmill at the gym listening to this, is this idea that we have a hand in sort of what do we want the fourth world to look like. If we are in this world where the places that we’ve normally gone for care, so Dwight’s opening questions there about where do we go for care, historically folks have gone to the church or they have gone to a therapist. And if we’re in a world where we’re not necessarily going automatically to those places, or those places look completely different, then where will we go? What does this fourth world look like?
So that’s a little bit of a broad brush of Rieff. I will hand it back over to Dwight, and Paul’s going to bring Lacan into the room for us.
Dwight Friesen: Well, you’ve already managed to transition there for me, Joel. But Joel, that kind of dare that you’re presenting to us, to imagine what it is to see ourselves as active agents in shaping the fourth world that we’re participating in, that’s a really interesting question to hold in the back of our minds as we continue on. So, thank you for that, Joel. Thanks for giving us that glimpse, and even into the glimpse of you on the treadmill.
Joel Kiekintveld: Probably not the glimpse you want.
Dwight Friesen: Well, what I mean by that is we’re all regular human beings trying to think and make sense of our lives. This is what education and formational work is all about. And so attending to the fact that we are real bodies in real places trying to make sense of our lives in order to care for our kids and our neighbors. This is real stuff.
And so with that in mind, let’s pivot over to Paul. Come on into the conversation, Paul, and bring with you Jacques Lacan. Give us a glimpse into there before we have the Rieff and Lacan dance together. Take it away, Paul.
Paul Hoard: All right. Okay. I’m trying to do this whole share my screen thing. Hopefully this is working. Okay. Yeah, thanks Dwight. And well, Joel, I always want to start responding right away before I have a chance to even say my part, because it’s exciting. Which is one of the reasons I love doing these kinds of discussions, because while we may have a plan of what we think we’re going to say, so much of this is sort of alive, even just listening to you say it right then and there, and kind of what’s coming up.
Well, so I’m going to talk a little bit about Jacques Lacan, which, if you haven’t heard about him, you’ve probably not been in one of my classes then, but also you are in good company, because he’s not well known in the US and in a lot of psychological spaces right now. So, Lacan was a French psychoanalyst who got popular predominantly after World War II and did most of his speaking and writing, these seminars he would give, from sort of the early ’50s until his death in the ’80s. And he was a French analyst, so most of his stuff is in French, and so he was writing in French, and so it was really difficult to translate a lot of his stuff. And so that’s part of why he hasn’t made it to the US and a lot of psych departments or mental health spaces, even in psychoanalytic circles in the US, until more recently, when there have been some better translations of him. But he is a fascinating thinker whom I continue to wrestle with, and just have found his thinking very similar to what you were saying, Joel, in terms of it’s inspiring, in terms of helping me find better ways to say things that I’ve been experiencing, finding new ways to communicate my experience, new ways to think about what’s going on, new ways to consider what’s happening both in the clinical space for me as a therapist, also in the educational and the supervisory space, but then also in the sort of academic, little bit more cultural reflective, kind of potentially sort of dabbling in the sociological. Lacan has some really interesting things that spark my thinking. So that I am excited to share at least a taste with you all today.
So, a couple things about him beyond where he was. He’s known, his sort of analytic thinking, his theory, bases a whole lot on language. And so I’m going to talk about one aspect of his theories, which is the discourses, and his theory of discourse. And I’ll explain a little bit more about that in a little bit. Other than to say he focused very heavily on language and the impact that language has on our consciousness, on what it means to be human, what it means to be a conscious being, what it means to think, and specifically, which we don’t have time to get into all of this, how that plays into the importance of desire. So desire and language are these two really important concepts for Lacan. I’ll talk a little bit about them today, but if any of that interests you, I would love to have a longer conversation with anybody that’s interested in it, because as my colleagues here know, I get excited whenever we can talk about Lacan, because he’s one of my passions.
But the part of him that I want to bring in today, as I mentioned, is his theory of the four discourses. And I’m going to walk you through some of it with the slides here in a moment. And I’m going to warn you ahead of time that these can feel archaic and complicated, and harder to hold on to. There’s going to be some weird symbols I’m going to have up there in a second. It’s not important that you hold on to the details of those symbols or anything. More that it hopefully gives you a way to begin thinking, perhaps in ways that you hadn’t thought before. That’s the whole point on my end of this, is to hopefully scaffold ways to think a little bit more deeply about some things that are hard to think about.
So with that said, Lacan’s idea of the discourses is that when he talks about a discourse, he’s actually interested in the relationship that’s formed through the act of speaking. When we begin talking to each other, he’s less interested in what we think we’re saying and much more interested in what relationship, what are the social bonds that are created through the very act of speaking. And so this is both on an interpersonal level, but also when we start thinking a little bit more sociologically, kind of in a broader sense, of what’s happening in the different types of discourses that we engage in. And so sitting down to listen to a pastor preach a sermon is both, there’s the content it’s about, but there’s something else happening in the fact of sitting in a pew and listening to somebody from a pulpit. There’s a relationship that’s engaged simply in the context, regardless of what that pastor says or what happens in your mind. And Lacan was really interested in that, in what we could say is the structure created in the act of speaking.
So, I’m going to walk you through some of his theories on this to hopefully give us some thoughts, and then I want to discuss with Joel how this can be in conversation with Rieff’s four worlds, and how maybe bringing these two very different ways of thinking together might kind of get us all thinking in new ways.
So, to start with, Lacan says when we talk, we can kind of look at, this is his theory of communication. There’s some basic components I’m going to put into place for us, and I’ll try to do this quickly, but you have an agent who speaks to an other. So right now, in this moment, I am an agent and I am speaking to you all. So this is sort of the basics in communication. I’m speaking. I have an idea of who I am. I have an idea of who you are, and I have some idea of what I think I’m trying to communicate to you all. And most communication theory agrees with some basic idea here.
What Lacan adds to this, and this is why my screen has these in four quadrants, is that there’s something else below that line, unconscious to both me as the agent and you as the other. There’s an other element to the act of me speaking. Something else is happening. I’m not just talking to you, but there’s actually, in the act of speaking, there’s a product that is happening. In other words, me speaking isn’t neutral. It does something in you. It does something to me. There’s something that’s produced by us engaging with each other.
And importantly, that product is separate and is distinguished from the truth, the idea that is actually motivating me to speak. And this is where Lacan’s psychoanalytic side starts coming in a little bit more, which would argue that one of the basic ideas of psychoanalysis is that we are not fully aware of ourselves. There’s always more to us. This is the way I like to talk about it, that there’s an unconscious element. So in me talking to you all right now in this webinar, I have an idea of why I think I’m here and what I think I want to say. Lacan would say, sure, that’s totally there. That’s absolutely part of it. And there’s more to it, Paul. There’s also more to the truth that is motivating you, Paul, to speak to these people right now in this webinar. And significantly, that truth and that product, what’s motivating and what the end results are, are not able to coalesce. There’s an impossibility in ever saying fully what you think you mean, and there’s a full inability of the motivator to be the product.
I know that gets convoluted and it’s a lot. What I mean by that is, this is actually the basis of talk therapy. If you’re really frustrated or you’re having a hard time, or you’re feeling some strong emotion or absence of emotion, and you come talk to a therapist, you don’t really know what you need to say or what you want to say, but you begin talking, and in the process of talking and discussing with a therapist, more is revealed and something else changes. What Lacan is trying to give us words for is, what’s that more and what’s the change? What’s the truth that’s motivating you to talk? Why are you explaining your feelings to that therapist? And then what’s the product? What happens when we actually engage with somebody else like that? There’s something more that happens. And so in these four quadrants, as we think about what’s happening in communication, Lacan says we can actually organize these into four distinct types of discourses, four distinct ways of engaging with one another, that what’s the truth that motivates us, who we think we are, who we think we’re talking to, and what the product is, changes.
Now, Lacan’s big kind of intervention here is to say that the discourse that we’re in, the structure that’s created in the act of speaking, is at the very least as important as what we think we’re saying. The act of sitting in a church listening to a sermon, for example, has its own impact regardless of what the pastor says. What the pastor says matters, but there’s something else happening in the act of having your body in that space, listening to them, engaging one another in that way, that it’s important for us to think about not just the content, but also what’s created in the structure.
Joel, I’m looking at you. Is this making sense? Okay, because I know I go a little bit far here. So, buckle your seat belts, because if you thought that was the confusing part, at least we still had full words. Now we’re heading into Lacan, what he called his mathemes. So he has these fun symbols here, which I know, take a breath, they’re okay. What we’re going to do is we’re going to take these four symbols and we’re going to put those into that quadrant of agent, other, truth, product, and depending on where they find themselves, it changes the kind of discourse. Who do you think you are when you’re speaking? What is motivating you to speak? Who do you think you’re talking to? And what’s the product of that? What’s fascinating is how, when we plug these in, it actually gives us really interesting different ways of understanding what’s going on in a conversation.
So the basic ideas, you’ll see this little a, this S1, S2, and this dollar sign. And what they stand for is, a is your object of desire. This is part of the translation from French, and object a as a little a in French versus little o in English. So bear with us. Then S1 is going to stand for sort of master. So this image of wholeness. S2 is going to stand for knowledge and words. And then the dollar sign is the split subject. And I don’t have time to go into all of what those mean, but sort of in religious discourse, this would be like, the master would be the priest, similar to what Joel was talking about. And knowledge would be like the religion, the text, what we say, all the different dogmas. And then the split subject would be either the saint or the witch, the good person or the bad person, the ways that we carry multiple within us. So just for example, but I’m going to apply these here with a couple more examples as we’re going along. So bear with me. Here we go.
So the first discourse that Lacan describes is called the discourse of the master. And this is where you are the speaker, the agent is taking the position of the one who knows. I currently think I know what I’m talking about, and I’m proclaiming the truth of what I think the world is. And I’m proclaiming it to an other, who may be my disciples, may be my student, may be my acolyte, may be my subscriber, who knows? But they’re going to take what I say and turn that into knowledge. Like, oh my goodness, it was this cryptic phrase he threw out there. That must mean all this other stuff, right?
And what happens though is that as I spew out more things that I think are true, and people turn that into knowledge that they think is useful, what’s created in that is desire. And if you think about a narcissistic leader, this is exactly what happens. They speak, their disciples hear it, it doesn’t make sense. So, they work hard to make it make sense. And the fact that it doesn’t make sense actually leads to more, oh my goodness, he must know so much more about this. She must be so much more knowledgeable. There must be so much more that I have to understand.
But the truth that stays hidden in this discourse of the master is that the master isn’t a master. Is that the master themselves is split, doesn’t know what they’re talking about, is also incomplete. That they can only stay as a quote “master” so long as there’s an other that’s supporting them. You’re only a leader if you have followers. You’re only a teacher if you have students. You’re only in charge if you have people who are willing to listen to you. And so this is sort of Lacan noting that the image of the master actually requires the other to follow. And so this always falls apart.
So, when it falls apart, then we move to what’s called the hysteric’s discourse, where now, wait a minute, I’m not together. I don’t know who I am. I’m not a master. I feel my splitness. I feel my anxiety. I feel my frustration. I feel that I need help. I am split. I am not whole. Something is wrong. And when I am in a position, and this perhaps takes you back to Dwight’s question at the very beginning of our webinar, of when you felt a need for care or a desire for care, you’re in this position of the split subject. You are in a position of need, of looking for help. And who do we turn to? We turn to someone who’s supposed to be in a position of knowledge, of certainty, of mastery, someone who’s supposed to be able to help. This sometimes looks like students who go to school because, oh my goodness, my world didn’t work, so I need to go learn from a professor who’s going to tell me. Or maybe I go to church so that my pastor or my priest can go tell me what’s going on. Or maybe I go to a therapist who’s supposed to help explain why am I this way. We turn to somebody else to be a master.
And what this discourse produces is that master will typically say things to you. They will explain the world to you. I will give you lectures if you come to my class. I will produce more knowledge. But importantly, what this discourse highlights is that the knowledge that I produce, the S2, what you learn in class, it might feel good in a moment, but it never really touches on the desire that motivated you to go searching in the first place.
In therapy, this is when a patient says, “Why am I anxious?” and I say, “Oh, you’re anxious because of your childhood and the way you were raised.” And maybe that’s true, but it doesn’t necessarily change the anxiety. There’s more knowledge, but that doesn’t touch some fundamental desire. And so the hysteric’s discourse is when we feel our lack, we feel something’s wrong, and we find somebody who’s supposed to know. We go to them and we say, “What’s going on?” And they say something, but it doesn’t actually work. And this is so much therapeutic interaction. It happens in schools all the time, when we are in the position of, but I want to know something.
So that’s one way things can fail. But the other direction they can fail is what Lacan called the university discourse. And this is where, instead of feeling our lack and leaning into it and finding someone to help us, instead what we do is we lean really heavily into the existing knowledge. This is when we go obsessive. We say, “Oh my goodness, I’m going to learn everything that every theologian ever wrote about this. I’m going to study everything that Freud ever said. I’m going to learn a whole bunch about this, so that I will be the one who can speak from, oh, let me tell you this, let me tell you that, and just explain everything.” And we’ll explain it to somebody else who wants it. Again, university discourse, like a professor who’s now the expert in Lacan, says it to somebody who’s supposed to be taking a class on Lacan. But what happens is the result, even though what they’re saying touches on some desire that that person has, what the result is, is that the listener still feels unsatisfied. There’s still a split. No matter how much Lacan you learn, you will not fully understand humans. It will not fully answer. You will simply feel, “Oh my goodness, I need to know more.”
In teaching counseling skills, I see this at this time of year, where I have students who are getting ready to go into internship, and it doesn’t matter how much I teach them about clinical practice or theory. That knowledge alone will never fully erase their imposter syndrome, because the knowledge itself actually produces that imposter syndrome, because it holds this fantasy that it could ever actually answer it. Because what has to stay hidden, the truth that motivates this discourse, is the idea that Lacan, or whoever the knowledge is built on, is true. That the science is actually accurate. That Freud knew what he was talking about. That Brené Brown’s research is absolute truth. Whatever it is we’re building it off of, that’s the thing that can’t be questioned. That’s the thing that has to stay hidden. We’ll simply talk about, well, what does the theory say, as if the theory itself is actually true.
So these three discourses, right? It’s important to note it’s not that one’s the good one, one’s the bad one, and one does this. It’s instead a curiosity of, when we talk, what’s motivating me? Am I in a position where I’m trying to use somebody else to hide my own unconscious, like, I don’t feel like I’m good enough, so I need you two to nod and smile at me, Dwight and Joel, to tell me I’m doing a good job? Is that what’s motivating me, where I need an other to sustain my image of myself? Am I looking to another person, a somebody, a master, to help answer questions for me, and there’s more things generated, but it doesn’t answer, and I still feel this constant search? Or am I obsessively trying to memorize something and understand it and get it so that I can have it down pat?
All of those can be productive, have places in our interactions. There are times we use other people. We look to somebody else. We look to somebody’s eyes to help clarify for us who we are. We speak in ways to other people because we have some knowledge that would be helpful for them. There are times we do learn about subjects and we share that. Lacan is not saying that the fact that these go around and don’t connect is the problem. It’s actually, can we be aware of what’s happening? So in churches, when we’re sitting down to listen to a sermon, or to sing together, or to commune, or to eat donuts and drink coffee afterwards, what’s happening in there? What are we looking for? And what’s the product?
The last discourse, and I’ll go through this one briefly, Lacan called the analytic discourse. And what I find really fascinating about this is that here, what’s taking the position of agent is actually the desire of the other. Here is where the split subject, the person who’s hurting, if you remember the hysteric’s discourse, is looking for a master, looking for someone to answer it. But instead of finding a master, they find a confrontation with their own desire, what they thought they wanted. And so there’s a disappointment, but there’s also now an openness, a possibility of finding something else. There’s obviously a lot more to this that we could get into, as to what else is going on and how this applies to analysis. But I want to pause my overly long, complicated lecture here, to bring Joel in to help us kind of make sense of this, because I think what I find really fascinating for our discussion is that question of, but what are we looking for, and who are we looking to, and what are we getting?
What are we looking for? Who are we looking to? And what are we getting? And if we can begin to be curious about that, I think this question of what are we looking for in care, where are we turning to for care, and what are we getting in that desire for care, I think it opens us up to be able to be more curious about it, to be able to connect with each other more, and find more ways of communal care, as opposed to slipping into more individualism and isolation. I’ll pause there and invite Joel and Dwight back in, and apologize to everybody for all the crazy graphs.
Dwight Friesen: Not at all. Paul, it is always a gift to see your glorious nerdiness. I just love it, and I love you. Okay. So, just before I invite Joel and Paul to just continue their conversation, but sort of in dance format, where Lacan and Rieff get to riff together, I just want to encourage you as a participant in this conversation to be writing down or entering your questions, or if you have any kind of responses or observations you would like Paul or Joel to respond to and kind of play with, go ahead and write those into our Q&A, and we’ll engage with that. But I just want to throw this one little thing in here as they begin to dance together. Here at the Seattle School, we’re going to prepare a person to be able to pass their licensure exams and all that kind of a thing. But we are not going to tell you what to believe and what is right and true. We actually are kind of in the place where we generally hold a stance that says that the work of theology, the work of psychology, is to continue the ongoing work of searching for the least inadequate language to describe the real. And that’s an interesting place to play. And I’m just going to throw that out there for now. You don’t have to riff with that, Paul or Joel, but as the two of you have listened to each other, and as you’ve heard yourself internally engaging, where do you want to take Rieff and Lacan as dance partners?
Paul Hoard: Well, okay. Actually, what I get excited about from what you just said, Dwight, is the thing that I’d written myself a note to get to, but I didn’t, which is that word play. I think sometimes when I engage with either ideas like Rieff’s or Lacan’s, there can be kind of a despair, that I feel like with Rieff, like, oh my goodness, okay, so we’re headed to authoritarianism, or we’re just going to look for another master, another sort of way to control us, and there’s no hope there. Or in Lacan, I’m never going to be able to communicate what I want to be able to, to get to where I’m going. There’s always going to be some form of failure in communication. And I think what the idea of play does is bring in, to say, “Yeah, ain’t that great?” And it switches the whole thing, where we move from, I think, what we called a finite game, of, I’ve got to make sure I say this just right, where I have to win this game, to playing the infinite game of, what keeps us playing with each other? And I think about this in terms of, we’ve had similar conversations to these, the three of us, before, but each time we do it’s different, and each time we do, something else happens, because it’s not actually that if, in the next half hour or whatever, we figured out, here is how Lacan and Rieff come together and here’s what you should go do about it, that would actually be the death of the conversation. That would be the end of the play. That would be the end of the infinite game. And it’s actually in the fact that we can continually look for better ways, or as you put it, the least worst way to talk about that, that we’re actually open to something more.
And so I think what play requires is being able to hold this both-and of, yeah, trying to solve the problem in front of me, and also holding that that problem isn’t the biggest problem, that there’s actually an ongoing desire, that there’s a movement towards, that we need to keep holding on to. So that, I don’t know, that’s the first thing that came to mind, particularly, Dwight, when you sort of brought it back to play and what we do here. But Joel, where’s your mind in that?
Joel Kiekintveld: Yeah, I mean, I think similar, Paul. You ended with kind of three things, and I only got two of them written down, but kind of, what are we looking for, who are we looking to? There was something else that you had in there.
Paul Hoard: And what are we getting?
Joel Kiekintveld: What are we getting. And those are my translations of what you were saying. But I think in what Lacan’s saying and in what Rieff’s saying, I think there’s a way to step back and look at it, and look at it as, we’re looking for something, and we’re trying to find something very certain to hold on to. And I don’t think we’re always aware, like Lacan says. And I’m glad you said, my initial response to Lacan when I first heard you talk about it was, I don’t want to talk about this. It’s like, why on earth would I want to talk about the fact that all communication’s essentially broken and can’t really happen? That’s super depressing. But I do think what he’s getting at around, we’re looking for something, and we’re not even always aware of what that is. And I think even if you look at Rieff’s stuff, so we look to the gods, or we look to the priest, or we look to the therapist, or whatever it is. And I think that’s what’s really interesting to me, is how do we get to a playful conversation or a playful interaction where we can say, well, we’re all looking for something and we don’t even always know what that is. And I think that’s, to me, what’s really interesting in this conversation, of how do we then open up spaces? We start thinking about spaces for care, or we start thinking about religious spaces. How do we open spaces that allow for that, of, I’m looking for something and I may not even totally know what that is. I might be able to name parts of it, but I don’t even know for sure what all I’m looking for. So that’s what’s going through my mind. There’s a bunch of stuff sparking there.
Paul Hoard: Well, because I think when we’re caught in the language I was using before, this finite game of, I need to find the thing, and that turns from desire to need, as if this is a requirement for my sustained survival, then if I think I found something helpful, I have to either consume it and realize it’s not perfect, and so I have to find something else, or I have to now defend that, no, this was it. And I think in Rieff’s language, it’s then, so that’s when we start arguing over, no, no, the first world was the good one, we need to go back to that. Oh, no, no, it’s the second one, we need to put religion back in. But, no, no, it’s this third one, no, let’s value the self. Instead of recognizing all of those offer something, right? There’s a beauty to the myth and to these sort of collective stories, and there’s value in organization, and there’s a lot of importance in understanding the person. It’s not that we need to now fight over which one is correct. But I think when we can open ourselves to, of course none of them are “it,” it actually allows each of them to have what they do, to offer us something. So we can then playfully recognize how easily our desire is captured.
This is one of the things I really enjoy about games, is how humiliating they are, because we’re going to sit down and we’re going to play the silliest game. We’ll play Uno, right? Something that’s just whatever hand you’re dealt. And yet my emotional world, my state, is going to be captured so quickly because now there’s a win condition or not. And I think one of those things that games keep showing you is, this thing is actually pointless, but you got so emotionally invested in that, Paul, it still captured who you are, in the same way that my desire gets captured by all sorts of things.
Even pretty fascinating right now: Lacan, of course, has captured my desire, and I almost kind of read and listen to and sort of talk about Lacan almost as if Lacan has the new Jesus, has answered all my questions. And if I forget that, no, that’s a game I’m playing with myself, that Lacan is helping me with something right now. Lacan is not the savior. Lacan is not the answer. That allows Lacan to be what he is, and also have been who he was, to be a real person and to offer me ideas, and for me to now wrestle with it. So, I think there’s something about the humility of play that becomes really helpful in holding this. Yeah, I would say the ultimate failure of communication, or of any approach for our desires.
Joel Kiekintveld: Yeah, I know I said earlier I was going to bring all my buddies in the room, invite extra people. So what’s going through my head with that is Hartmut Rosa, the sociologist, talks about, we just try to control the world. That’s what we do in the modern world. And he goes into all these different ways that we try to control it, and he said ultimately it’s uncontrollable. And he has this idea of what we’re actually looking for, and he might be right, and I have to be very careful with what you just said, because I can put him on a pedestal as well. One of the things I appreciated in one of his most recent works is he’s like, I came at all this stuff from sociology only to discover that theologians have been talking about it forever. He was just kind of like, what do you know? But he talks about this idea of resonance. We’re looking for something that we connect to, that sparks us and wants us to do something in the world. And he says ultimately, though, it’s all uncontrollable. We can’t make it happen. And that’s kind of what I hear a little bit in what you’re saying, is we want to latch on to all these things because then that gives us a sense of control. Which maybe ultimately, maybe that’s what our hidden desire is, right? Is we really want to be in charge of everything. But that’s where I find Rosa really helpful, of, it’s not controllable. Resonance shows up when it shows up. The world does what it does. Like your Uno illustration, you’re dealt the hand that you’re dealt in some ways.
Paul Hoard: Yeah.
Joel Kiekintveld: And we can’t totally control that. So yeah, that’s what just…
Paul Hoard: And I think it’s easy to hear that and then shame ourselves for wanting that control, and say, “Oh, so I shouldn’t want that. Bad, Paul. How dare you,” instead of being able to recognize, oh, what’s that control doing for me? Why am I feeling that? And how does that help me better understand myself, better understand what we’re doing right now, which allows me to better recognize Dwight’s desire for, maybe it’s control, but maybe control touches on something else, and maybe that gives us a way to connect with each other. And I think this is where, when we enter this conversation around beyond pews and couches, I think my first blush with our title like that is to sort of be like, look, we’re going to show how both churches failed you, haha, and how therapists failed you, and we’re going to give you the right thing, right? And sort of dunk on these other ways of getting care and make everybody feel like, oh, I’m supposed to get care this way, this is the right thing to do.
And I think instead what I hear us begin to talk about, and let me know, Dwight and Joel, where you’re going with this, but is actually to say there’s something really beautiful people have gotten out of faith communities. There’s something really beautiful that has done that. And of course faith communities have not provided absolutely everything, and there’s a lot of harm that’s come from trying to, from their misuse, from their abuse, from their sort of overreach, or from looking for too much out of them. And so similarly, I’d say there’s obviously wonderful healing that has come from therapy. I’ve dedicated my life to being a counselor. I believe in what this is doing. And I don’t think therapy alone is going to save the world. I don’t think therapy is the thing that’s going to save everyone. Therapy is a way to help, or particularly talk therapy is a way to help, some people with some issues for some time, and it’s a particular thing.
And so I think if we can enter into this conversation with this curiosity, like you’re saying, of, what is it we’re looking for? Is it control? And then who are we looking to, and what are we getting from that? Because sometimes we are getting really helpful things. I’ve been in therapy for a very long time, and it’s been really helpful, and it has not been everything. It has not solved all my problems. Thank goodness. I’m so glad it hasn’t, because this is why I keep joining other communities and continuing to learn and to grow. And so I think on one hand there’s a recognizing, of course we have a desire for something, and that desire itself isn’t problematic. What I think becomes dangerous is when we try to convince ourselves we’ve found it, or to try to feel like we have to rescue other people too much, that we have to negate any value that they’ve experienced, instead of using our desires to understand how we can better connect with each other in a very shifting world. We don’t know what comes next. But I loved how you ended with that dream of the fourth world and what our responsibility is in that.
Joel Kiekintveld: There’s… Oh, go ahead, Dwight.
Dwight Friesen: I was just going to say we’ve got a whole host of great questions burgeoning, and so we’ll get to maybe pivot to those. Joel, why don’t you respond with what you were going to say, and then let’s draw in some of the insights and questions that folks are raising.
Joel Kiekintveld: Yeah. I mean, as quick as Paul moves to games, I probably move to music, or to baseball. We won’t get into baseball today, but there’s two songs that are running through my head as I’m thinking about this. And I think artists help with some of this, of, they’re trying to name some of this stuff that we nerds want to draw diagrams with weird things and come up with worlds and all these different things. But U2’s, “I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For” is one of those things, of, there’s this search of, I’m looking for something, I’m looking for something. And they say it other ways in other songs. The other song that comes to mind is Daws. I was at a music festival a couple years ago. Had never heard them before, and they started playing this song, and the singer is going through all these things that they’ve done, and the turnaround line is “But it didn’t fix me, it didn’t fix me like I thought it would.” And it’s like the whole song is this search for things.
And I think when we talk about beyond pews and couches, I do think, Paul, you’re right. There’s this sense of, we can throw all these other things under the bus, but I think there’s still some desire underneath there that we’re looking for. There was an article a couple years ago in The Atlantic where the author talked about millions of Americans have abandoned religion only to recreate it everywhere they look. And what I got out of that was, there’s something inside of us that wants this connection with other people, with meaning that’s bigger than us, with however we want to name that, and we keep kind of looking for it in lots of different places. And we might find that in a pew, and we might find that in a couch, but we might find that in a stadium, or who knows where. And I think getting to the beyond is to that, what is the desire that we’re looking for, and how do we help folks lean into that a bit.
Dwight Friesen: Yeah. I’m going to jump in with a brief question for you, Joel, first, right off the bat. This has to do with Rieff’s imagination that this fourth component is imminent, that it is on the cusp. And the other ones seem to take centuries to kind of see some movement that way. And the question kind of had to do with the idea of, what are the indicators that would, how do they say it? Basically, how would you distinguish the fourth one? Why now? Why is it so imminent?
Joel Kiekintveld: You’re looking at Kate’s question from the Q&A. Yeah. I think for Rieff, the issue was, he was really focused on, there has to be some kind of structure, right? So for him, the therapeutic world looks like there’s no structure. And we see that, we see the products of that in some ways, of, we now live in a world that’s full of alternative facts, whatever the heck that means, right? So we have a hard time even deciding what is truth at the moment, of definable facts. And that’s where ultimately, in some ways, a very individualized world leads us. And I think for Rieff, that was very unstabilizing. He wanted some kind of system or structure that would give, he would use the term morality, but give a control to the world.
My take on that is that what makes it feel like there’s maybe a shift happening is that idea that people continue, what we were just talking about, people continue to look for something to fill whatever this desire is. So that means that these previous ways, I mean, they worked for a while. And there’s reasons, I mean, we could go into the history of why did the church, why did this work for a while? I mean, there’s a lot of control, a lot of cultural control, a lot of power that made that the thing. And why is there in therapy, like Paul said, therapy is really good. Therapy also has downsides, right? Church is good in some ways, has downsides. And for me, I think the thing is, I feel like people are still wrestling with the same questions, but they’re skeptical of these other systems. And that’s why I wonder if we’re still not in some kind of sorting phase of going into something new. So, I don’t know if that answers the question.
Dwight Friesen: No, I think that gets at it. That’s good.
Okay. So, this can be for either of you or both of you, and this is kind of a mashup, I think, of a couple of questions that came in. But both Rieff and Lacan seem to be working at the edge of what we used to call sort of postmodernism, or sort of after World War II, there’s that kind of moment. How aware, or how in that conversation… how am I missing? I’m sorry. How were they aware or in that conversation, reacting to this context? I’m sorry, I’m reading this very poorly. Talk to me about the context of after World War II. Let’s go there.
Joel Kiekintveld: So Paul and I have had this conversation a couple of different times in different ways, and I like it because it’s sort of jazz every time. It’s a little bit different, even though we’re starting from the same place. And I wrote down this time, it’s interesting, it is interesting to me, and I hadn’t caught this before. They’re both working in a similar time period, right? They’re working in this post-World War II world. And whether you call that postmodernism, or you look at it through the lens of somebody like Jürgen Moltmann, who’s trying to figure out, what do you do now with the world, now that we’ve seen the greatest war in human history? People claimed God was on their side in both of these world wars. I think it is that milieu of the post-World War II world, where things had literally been blown apart physically, for sure. I mean, Europe was a disaster. We blew up whole cities in Japan. But I think also it had messed up so much of what the structure of understanding the world was for the western world, that they were asking these questions. And they may not have called it postmodernism. Like I said, I haven’t taken a super deep dive into Rieff, but they were definitely in that world of, now all these questions are swirling in light of these impacts that these two world wars have had in this short period of time.
Dwight Friesen: Good.
Paul Hoard: Yeah, I think, I mean, I try to be cautious. Having never interacted personally with Lacan, I obviously don’t know all the nuances of his story, so I can speculate from my chair here. But I do imagine, I mean, particularly a lot of the French intellectuals coming out of World War II were coming out of this experience of just the devastation and the horror, that I think is really different from what particular intellectuals in the US were experiencing, where yes, Americans experienced war, but beyond Hawaii, it was not the lived experience of many people in their homes, watching their families be a part of it, being under sort of the Nazi regime that you had in France in World War II.
And so I do think there is something about seeing, oh, the logical conclusion of where we’re headed, of seeing what this does, of sort of that fantasy of expansion and of progress and of modernity is going to take us to good places. I think there’s something about the reality of that being lived in a way that caused some of these, particularly I think Lacan and some of the French intellectuals, to think in a very different way. That’s not my full area of study. I want to be careful that I’m not talking completely, but that’s sort of where my mind goes with this, sense of this awareness of the failure and the hubris of thinking we can figure it out, that we’ll figure it out and it’s going to work out, and that sort of positivism that I think comes from it. And instead this openness to, actually, it’s in our failure that there’s something else that can happen. It’s in our failure that there’s more that can be explored.
Dwight Friesen: Okay, I’m going to jump in with another question here, and I’ll just read it directly. “How does what Paul is saying about play…” So this is for you, Paul. “How does what Paul is saying about play speak to the way we look to Jesus as savior or as answer?”
Paul Hoard: Yeah, I can tell you how I think it speaks to it, but I will let the theologians in the house maybe say more on that in terms of interpretation. So maybe this is more of a Joel question.
So play, when I use the word play, there’s a lot there, and it’s one of these kind of really significant terms for me that organizes my world in really helpful ways. And so I say that more as a caveat, that sometimes when people hear me talk about play, and I use examples like Uno, they instantly go, and they think of childish things, or they think of frivolous, or they think of silly. Play isn’t important. Work is, right? If you’re doing something important, you’re working. If you’re doing something unimportant, you’re playing. And I wholeheartedly reject that. But I am aware that that is what often comes in people’s minds. So the first thing I want to say is, I’m not saying this is unimportant, frivolous, or silly. In fact, I think some of the most important and beautiful aspects are when we are able to play.
And I’ll say, as a dad, and this I think comes into, starts impacting a lot of my theology and my own personal relationship with religion and faith and the Jesus narrative, the amount of joy I experience watching my children play together is incredible. One of my favorite things in life is seeing my children play well with each other. And there’s something deeply theological, I think, about a God who desires us to play with one another, us to play with that God, and us to play with each other. And I think an invitation into an infinite game of playing with each other, not because the game is silly, but actually because that’s actually where beauty and connection comes from.
And I think it’s our own desires to want to force meaning onto things, or to feel purposeful, or to feel control, like you were saying, Joel, that we downplay, we denigrate play, and we raise work up. But one of the beautiful things about play is that it has to point beyond itself. Because it points to, I can’t posit my own meaning. And so I have to be open to something fun that erupts into our world when we engage a game playfully. If you pursue fun by itself, you rarely get there. But if you actually play a game and try to win, you actually often have fun. It’s this sort of byproduct that has to happen.
And so I think there’s something about Jesus, and the way I kind of read the Christian scriptures, of giving us a way to pursue Jesus, but also to play with the Spirit, to pursue the Father, or to pursue the divine in a playful way, where something more happens. And I think that’s part of what I would argue the liturgy of the church is intended, is to help us play our way through that, and that it opens us to something more. I mean, it’s always fascinating to talk to somebody and, like I said, there’s a little humility of, I can’t believe I got that upset about an Uno game, or I got that invested in an Uno game. And if we’re open to it, we learn so much about ourselves when we play, which I think is often why we’re afraid to play in front of each other, because you might find out how competitive I am. You might find out what aspects of me aren’t all buttoned up and professorial. And I think that’s actually where community and God… I think I’ve probably lost the plot now, so I’ll stop talking and let Joel answer.
Joel Kiekintveld: Yeah, I mean, a couple of images come to mind. I mean, one is literally when the church figures out, you know, we’re sort of in this period in the New Testament where Jesus’ death and resurrection and ascension, and then it feels like when you have one of those experiences where you’re like, “Okay, now I got to figure out, now what was that?” And the church goes through this period of, “What was that?” where they’re trying to sort stuff out. And after they kind of arrive at the doctrine of the Trinity, they’re trying to describe what the Trinity does, and they just go, “Well, the Trinity dances.” And I think we want an ABC, right? Or a hierarchy or whatever. And they’re like, “No, it’s a dance.” So that’s one thing that comes to mind, is that feels very playful, of, even in the midst of how does God interact with God’s self, is in a dance. That feels very playful.
But the other thing that comes to mind is, I think Jesus, I mean, not always, but often, is playful in what he’s saying. The parables are often really playful, and we read them in a different way, but the one that comes to mind, and I’m terrible with where passages are found, so thank goodness for Bible Gateway and other things, but Jesus tells the story of the garden. He’s like, imagine you have a garden, and you have a mustard seed, and you plant it, and the story then invites all the things gardeners do not want in their garden. That plant takes over everything. The birds show up. What gardener wants birds in their… you know? It’s this playful story that then you’re left with, what does it mean that the kingdom of God is like this garden where the mustard seed takes over and invites all these birds or whatever into my garden? Because most of us that garden want to have everything just so, right? And we plant what’s there and, you know, there’s a whole theory of chaos gardening. That’s a different thing, and I actually think it’s beautiful. But we want a lot of control, right? And Jesus is telling this story where the garden gets all kind of goofed up, and that feels very playful.
The last image for me is the, and I have to be careful here because I don’t think this is the answer for everyone, the faith community I’m a part of moved away from sort of everything-up-front sermon listening to a very discussion-based model. And part of that is, things don’t resolve a lot of the time, and folks are able to bring, hopefully are comfortable to bring, who they are to the space and to ask questions and then to play with it. So I knew we were getting somewhere in our community when somebody brought a question and started out with, “This might be heresy, but…” Because in most of our circles, those questions… to be able to take this question. And in that case it was a psalm, these psalms where the beginning is all beautiful, wonderful, glowy things about God, and the end of it’s the ones where it’s like, kill my enemies and let the blood run in the street and all. And they were like, “God feels like he’s got a split personality.” And we were able to pick that passage up then and play with it. Not in a frivolous sense, but in the way you’re describing, Paul, of, how do we go into all these areas and kind of turn the gem and see what does this all have to say to us? And it might connect to everybody in that group in a different way. People may have all left with something different. But that feels more playful to me. There’s lots of ways that goes all kinds of wrong, and I don’t have time to go into that, but that I think is what we’re being invited into. And I think Jesus invites us into that with the parables too, of, he rarely explains them. He just kind of throws this idea out there in this way and tells this story, and then I think we’re supposed to play with it and turn it over and discuss it.
Dwight Friesen: I know my primary role here is moderator. I’m supposed to be bringing the questions and not responding to the questions. But I just want to add a little piece here, because so much of what Jesus does is, Jesus is railing against all forms of empire in his ministry. It’s not all Jesus is doing, but certainly anything that’s seeking to control, to oppress, and to exclude, Jesus seems to be pushing against. So every time Jesus says “the kingdom of God is like,” or “the kingdom of heaven,” Jesus is pushing against systems of oppression.
And play refuses oppression. Play is the antidote to oppression. Oppression seeks to control and win it, or claim it all. And I think that part of what Jesus is doing is subverting any system. And I think that’s part of the invitation of this era, is, who will the church become? Will we become a people of play? As Rieff imagines this fourth era, as we think together about how we are using language and what does it mean, do we need to collapse into our certainties and run back to the things that we think that we know or whatever? Or is there a way, as a people, to maybe let go of the work of the people and discover what the play of the people might look like? What might it look like for us to keep in step, dance step, with the Spirit, or something to that effect?
Dwight Friesen: Okay. Another question that’s coming to us. This has to do with AI, and I’d love to hear you all respond to this. Would or could AI be considered a new master? How do you see our society’s draw to AI solving all of our problems, and even looking to AI to provide care? How does that fit into this conversation, or does it?
Paul Hoard: I have a lot of thoughts on this one, but Joel, I don’t want to dominate if you’ve got some.
Joel Kiekintveld: I will say very quickly, I think absolutely that there are folks who are looking for AI to be the new… I mean, think about it. If you can build a machine that can answer any question that you’ve ever wanted to ask in your whole life and give you an answer, what’s more certain than that, right? And we know currently there’s a lot of limitation. AI doesn’t always give you… it can’t even give me citations that are correct half the time. So we know there’s some limitations. Paul and I have had a couple of conversations about this. I’ve been thinking for a while about the Luddites back in England, of, and this gets a little bit away from the question, but their main concern was not so much technology, but what technology was going to do to people. And I think we need to in some way craft sort of a Luddite theology of, how do we remain human even though we have this amazing tool that can do all this stuff? It’s fantastic, but how do we not lose the humanness in that? And I think that’s the danger, when we look at it as this ultimate Wizard of Oz sort of answering machine, the thing behind the curtain. But I know Paul’s been working on AI a ton. Well, so has Dwight. So I’d love to hear both your thoughts as well.
Paul Hoard: Yeah. No, I love that, because I think where my mind quickly goes is not just, is this thing a good thing or a bad thing, but how are we using it? How are we being formed in our use of it, right? I mean, when the pandemic hit and we all moved online and I started doing teletherapy, the big question wasn’t just, okay, can I talk to my patients? Yes, I can. But how is my patient being formed by talking to me through a computer versus sitting in my office? There’s a formational aspect of who we are becoming in the tools that we use. First, we make tools, and then tools remake us. And I think that’s actually a huge aspect of what’s going on.
But it’s a great question, because I’ve actually done some writing on my blog around taking Lacan’s discourses and applying it to AI, because I think there’s some really fascinating things happening. So, if you’ll indulge me for a quick moment, what I’ll say is that AI is fascinating as opposed to something like, when I was younger, Ask Jeeves, or even the way we use Wikipedia, because we approach it in a very different discourse. So with traditional sort of encyclopedias of knowledge, be that Wikipedia or the Encyclopedia Britannica or whatever, we would approach them a little bit more sort of out of this master’s discourse, where, okay, hey, tell me the thing, give me the thing. And then I’ll go home and I go to it and I ask it to do a thing, but I’m using that knowledge to help me maintain my sense. When I have an Amazon Echo device that my kids love to play Frozen songs on, and K-pop Demon Hunters, and so they will tell it to do things. They’re not looking to it to provide care for them.
But what’s interesting in some of the shift that’s happening with AI is that instead of approaching it as a master’s discourse, of the master I described, we’re actually approaching it as a hysteric’s discourse. And so I think the question actually is really, really spot-on. When we’re approaching it expecting it to be the master, expecting it to tell us what’s up. I go to ChatGPT and say, “I’m feeling bad. What should I do?” I am expecting it to somehow help me feel better. If I have a question, like you said, Joel, about anything in the universe, I’m going to go to it and hope it will answer it. And this may not be my conscious fantasy, but I would argue part of what’s happening is this hope that, oh, if I get this, then I’ll be okay. I’m going to it now with a sense of, something’s off. I am the split subject. And what the result of that, though, is that it can’t be the master, because AI is actually simply a compendium, at best, of our existing knowledge, which it doesn’t even do that perfectly well, because it often gets those wrong, like you just said, and mixes things up. But all AI is, is knowledge, in the language of the discourses. It’s that S2. It’s just knowledge. It’s not actually a human or a consciousness that’s split, that can connect through our own lack. And so there’s this huge mismatch between how we’re approaching it, looking to it to take care of us, but it’s going to continually spit information at us. And so it’s going to keep us in this loop of this university discourse, where we keep wanting more.
And I think that’s where this sort of very dangerous, on one hand, almost addictive process, where we feel the lack, so then I keep asking it. And on top of the way it’s been designed to keep us going, to keep us asking, to keep us engaged, and to continue to make us think that quick answers, summaries, bite-size responses are going to be best, as opposed to when you talk to a person. Even talking to a professor who might give you a quick response, there’s an awareness and an openness to, actually, there’s an entire book behind that answer. There’s so much more happening, and there’s now an interaction between us. It’s a very different thing.
And so, just to end my thought here, I’ll try to land this plane quickly. But when we engage AI as a split subject looking to a master, we get knowledge and response. When we do that in therapy, where a client comes to my office and is looking for me to tell them why they’re anxious, to solve their trauma, to fix whatever is going on, that’s when, when things go well, I actually move into the analytic discourse, where instead of giving them an answer, we actually reveal a little bit more of how their world is structured and what their own unconscious desires are, and I become a screen of their desire. I can explain more of that theory at some other time. But there’s a process by which my lack, my inability to answer that, becomes part of the therapeutic process.
AI can’t do that. It will always pretend to try to answer for you. It’ll always have another answer. It’ll always have more to say. And so, it continues this spin of us continuing to look for more. Does that mean it’s always an unhelpful tool? No. I think there are use cases for AI, but I think we need to be really careful about how it is forming us and how it is helping us, because I think there’s just a comment about, AI doesn’t give us play. AI itself can’t play. I think you could play with AI, but AI is not a player with you. It is a tool, like rolling dice. You can play with dice. You can roll your dice and have fun with your game, but the dice itself is not a co-player with you. I have a lot more on that. Happy to chat. But I love the question, because I think it’s a really important way to think about not just what am I saying to Claude, but what’s happening in the very act of me going to Claude with a question, looking for an answer. I take us back to, what am I looking for? What’s the care I’m trying to seek from a machine? Who am I going to? What does it mean that I would go to a computer, to Claude, to an AI, to an LLM? And then what do I actually get? I may get knowledge that I think is helpful, but am I actually getting the care that would actually move me towards thriving? Joel, you’re going to say something there?
Dwight Friesen: Joel, you were gonna say something. You got it. Go for it.
Joel Kiekintveld: No, I don’t have anything to add to that.
Paul Hoard: I got excited there. Sorry.
Joel Kiekintveld: Go to Paul’s Substack.
Dwight Friesen: So much of what you’re saying in there, Paul, and Joel, in responding to that AI question, underscores to me why the work that we’re seeking to do at the Seattle School has never felt more important to me than ever before. I mean, this is unofficial, but I would say that the two deep things that the unofficial curriculum of the Seattle School is, is deep listening and opening to human flourishing for all and everything. And that’s an inherently, or intrinsically, playful space to move into. Which leads us into what will probably end up being our final question. And I say that just because there are so many good questions that we didn’t get to them all. We’re not even close. So I’m going to encourage those of you whose questions didn’t get addressed to send emails to Joel or Paul, and they will be happy to respond. I’m speaking for you.
But here’s this question that I’d like us to sort of conclude with, and it’s this: How does a person balance or imagine this lack of control being healthy with concrete bodily-based commitments in a therapeutic setting? So do you hear what they’re trying to ask there? How do you balance this lack of control being healthy with concrete bodily-based containment in a therapeutic setting? Riff with that a little bit.
Joel Kiekintveld: I’ll let the therapist go with that one.
Paul Hoard: Yeah. So, I’ll play with language here for a second, because Lacan does this well. And I’m going to give a distinction between needs and desires here that I think are really important. And I want to be careful with this. So if you mishear this, please come back. I’d love to have a longer conversation with you about how I’m using these, because I’m trying to be careful.
Lacan distinguishes needs as things that can be met, from desires as that which can never be satisfied but keeps us alive. Needs are important. This is not to say one is important and one isn’t. This is not a question of value. This is a question of what’s possible. Needs can be met. And I think those sorts of needs for containment, for bodily containment, for safety, that’s a thing that we should provide, right? There are needs that my children have for me to provide as a caretaker for them. I do need to provide, maybe on a physical level, I need to provide food and water and shelter and all of that. And then there’s also an emotional level. I need to provide care and love and all those sorts of things.
And then there’s a desire my kids have that can never be satisfied by me having loved them enough, right? There’s a desire that pushes beyond that, that keeps us continuing to play with each other, to continue to pursue. So where I hear it is, absolutely there is a question of needs within a therapy room, within personal care, within a person’s biological needs, within a person’s abilities and all of that. And the part that I get nervous about is when everything becomes a need. And what I mean by that is that it falls under the fantasy that it can all be satisfied. Whereas your desire to be known, your desire to be loved, your desire to connect, your desire for affection, I hope you’re never satisfied with that. I hope my partner doesn’t come to me and say, “Well, good, I got enough love from you, thanks,” and then walk away. Actually, it’s in us continuing to move towards each other that that becomes life. So absolutely there are needs, but the distinction I would simply make is, what can be satisfied, and what should be continually pursued, because the pursuit itself does something.
Dwight Friesen: Oh, thank you. We could honestly talk… I’m going to pause us there. We just… it’s so rich. It’s so good. Well, okay, my friends, I’m going to turn it back to Lauren in just a second, but before we do, I want us to just practice gratitude for just a few moments together. We’ve just spent an hour and a half in conversation, and in hearing our friends, hearing Paul and Joel, open us up to this conversation. I would love for you to just listen to your body, listen to your heart and your mind. What’s the swirl inside? What are you sensing? And take a moment and reflect on, what are you holding gratitude for? What insight or connection or hope? Is there a person, a word, an image, a feeling? I’d invite you to listen for that, to name it to yourself, give thanks for that. And if you wish, I’d encourage you to post what you’re holding gratitude for, with specificity, in our chat, for just a few moments. So, I’d invite you to just listen to yourself, hold gratitude, and then post it there.
[Pause for reflection]
Hey Lauren, I’m going to invite you, even as these people’s posts are popping in, just let your eyes fall over that. What a gift. What a gift to be together. Lauren, close us out. What do we need to know?
Lauren Peiser: Thank you all so much. That was very fun. I didn’t know slides and Lacan and Rieff could be so playful. So thank you. That was great. And thank you all for being here. It’s awesome to see the chat and see y’all’s engagement.
So before we end, we have a small request for you all. We are actually starting to build out more community classes, and we have a super short survey. It’s two minutes at most, to ask questions about what you all would be interested in, what topics you’d like to hear, what type of format you’d like to see it in. So we would love for you to fill out that survey. And if you do fill it out, you will be entered in a chance to win two books from our faculty. One is Eucontamination by Dr. Paul Hoard and his sister Billie Hoard, and the other one is Growing Up Pure by Dr. Lauren Sawyer.
And so if you are joining live, I just put that in the chat. I’ll add it again here so you have it. I’ll also send that in email afterwards, too. And then we’ll send the slides in a PDF version so you can go back and look at those again. And if you’re watching this on YouTube, the link for the survey is in the description. And our next online conversation is coming up June 25th, and that is with Dr. Lauren D. Sawyer, who wrote the book. And she is going to be talking about how the purity culture movement co-opted and used therapeutic language, and the implications of that. So, I’m really excited about that one, too. I hope you all sign up for that. But thank you so much, Dwight, Joel, and Paul. That was super fun. And thank you to everyone who joined us today, and we look forward to doing more of these soon. So, thank you all so much. Bye.
Dwight Friesen: Thank you.